Tuesday, June 16, 2009

What is Really Happening in Iran

***This is information from TATSUMA on the Fark.com message boards. He is the resident expert. This IS NOT an aratdisc article***

Warning, new twitter feeds are most likely government members trying to spread misinformation, ignore them! Also, there is a handful of good twitter feeds, but please do not publicize their usernames, they are in enough danger as it is and they don't need more publiclity. Those in the know will c/p their entries. Major timeline overhaul, including what has unfolded in the last few hours.

This seems to be helping quite a few people, so I'll go ahead and repost it in every threads with some adjustments. Sorry, this has reached the level of TL;DR but I really am trying to cram the most relevant information and speculation only. Everything is updated as events unfold, especially the timeline and what will happen in the future.

Suppression of Dissent - The Players

Currently, there are either two or three groups who are suppressing the students on the ground that you'll read about throughout this thread:

1. The Basij
2. Ansar Hizbullah (which I will refer to as Ansar)
3. Lebanese Hizbullah (Unconfirmed but highly probable. Der Spiegel, based on a Voice of America report, says that 5,000 Hizbullah fighters are currently in Iran masquerading as riot police, confirming the independent reports. Many different independent reports and video point that way. Even in the last hours other independent twitter feeds have declared witnessing thugs beating on people while shouting in Arabic; I will refer to them as Hizbullah)

- The Basij are your regular paramilitary organization. They are the armed hand of the clerics. The Basij are a legal group, officially a student union, and are legally under direct orders of the Revolutionary Guard. Their main raison d'être is to quell dissent. They are the ones who go and crack skulls, force people to participate in pro-regime demonstrations, and generally try to stop any demonstrations from even starting. They are located throughout the country, in every mosque, every university, every social club you can think of. They function in a way very similar to the brownshirts.

They were the ones who first started the crackdown after the election, but it wasn't enough. While they are violent and repressive, they are still Persian and attacking fellow citizens. A beating is one thing, mass killings another.

- Another group was working with them, whose members are even more extreme, is Ansar. There is a lot of cross-membership between the Basij and Ansar, though not all are members of the other group and vice-versa. The vast majority of Ansar are Persians (either Basij or ex-military), though a lot of Arab recruits come from Lebanon and train with them under supervision of the Revolutionary Guard. They are not functioning under a legal umbrella, they are considered a vigilante group, but they pledge loyalty directly to the Supreme Leader and most people believe that they are under his control. They are currently helping the Basij to control the riots, but due to the fact that they are Persians and in lower numbers than the Basij, they are not that active.

- The Lebanese Hizbullah is a direct offshoot (and under direct control) of the Iranian Hizbullah (itself under direct control of the Supreme Leader) and cooperates closely with Ansar though Ansar occupies itself only with Iran's domestic policies, while Hizbullah occupies itself only with Iran's foreign policy unless there is a crisis like right now. However, Hizbullah has been called to stop violent riots in Iran in the past.

(the following paragraph includes some speculation based on reports from ground zero) Hizbullah flew in a lot of their members in Iran, most likely a good deal even before the elections in case there were trouble. They are the ones who speak Arabs and are unleashing the biggest level of violence on the Persians so far. Another wave arrived recently and there is chatter that yet another wave of Hizbullah reinforcements are coming in from Lebanon as we speak. According to Iranians on the ground, they are the ones riding motorcycles, beating men women and children indiscriminately and firing live ammunitions at students.

What will happen

Unless the army decides to intervene in the favor of the Council and to stop the early beginnings of the new Revolution, Ansar & Hizbullah members will be the ones doing the brunt of the killing and repression with Basij as a support while also protecting government buildings and try to do crowd control. The police seems to have for the most part disbanded in centers like Tehran according to all reports, including international media. If the police decides to come back, they will focus less on protection and crowd control, so the Basij will start to crack more skulls).

Currently, this is what is happening.


Timeline (updated and revamped!)
note: I built this through both articles and twitter feeds, so I do not claim that this is a 100% factually correct representation of reality, but this is the general narrative.

14th of June - While the previous day had been witness to some protests, they were for the most part peaceful. However, as time grew the protests turned more and more violent. When the first spontaneous riots erupted, the first wave of violence was unleashed. The Iranian Riot Police was called in to support the regular police officers controlling the protests, and shortly after the Basij also took the scene, moving from a passive to active role of repression. The RP concentrated mostly around public buildings and streets while the Basij took position around student groups, especiallly universities.

- As things got more out of hand, more and more Basij troops were called in, as the police started dispersing. The riot police are less inclined (or, rather I should say the Basij are more inclined) to use violence so they retreated and leaving the place to the Basij. The repressive forces concentrated their assault mostly around the main Iranian universities, while the riot police were concentrating on protecting various government buildings such as the Interior Ministry. At least two people had been killed already.

- On the telecommunication front, this is when we started to hear more and more from twitters while videos were being freely updated to youtube (while youtube started to delete the more violent ones a few hours later). This is also the moment where the government realized what was happening, and ordered for the internet, phone lines and cellphones to be cut off, in order to avoid people communicating with the outside world.

late 14th, early 15th of June - This is the second wave of violent repression. At this point, violent riots had spread all over the main cities of Iran. The violence against citizens was not only the fruit of the Basij anymore, but also came from Ansar Hizbullah members. This is the point where firearms started being used. There were reports of a few murders but it was mostly fired in the air or on walls in order to scare away protesters in University dorms. It's also around the same time that the first reports and videos of an important number of non-Persian thugs shouting in Arabic and violently beating people with chains, clubs and electric batons (similar to cattle prods), which led to many speculating that lebanese Hizbullah members were now in Iran. Der Spiegel, through Voice of America, later claimed that 5000 Hizbullah fighters were passing off as Riot Police, validating the claims of many independent sources and twitter feeds.

- Universities have been the hotbed of protests, serving as a hub of anti-government demonstrations and preparations. 120 teachers from the Sharid University resigned in protest over the election results. Perfectly away of this, the Basij, Ansar and possibly Hizbullah members concentrated their attacks on University Dorms all over the country, storming them and beating students, destroying everything, especially computers.

- The end of the second wave came right before the beginning of the current manifestation. Things were getting quieter with only sporadic reports of dissenters being assaulted. Important to note: at this time. the Supreme Leader authorized the plainclothes militias to use live ammunition against the crowd if things were to get out of hands. By the end of the first two waves of protests, hundreds of people had been arrested.

midday, 15th of June - This brings us to the third wave, which just began around 12:30PM for those of us on the East Coast. Plainclothes militia opened fire on civilians protesting peacefully. Possibly up to 2 million protesters took the street. Chaos erupted in the streets, with reports of fighting all over Tehran and spreading over Iran as the news circulated. Pictures of people shot, some to death, finally surfaced and were published in the mainstream media. Violent and murderous repression has started. At least a twenty people had been killed at this by the end of the 15th of June.

- There is a major national crackdown on students, especially those with connections to the outside world going on right now. Students are fighting back in some areas. Telephones are being bugged and everyone twittering and sending videos outside of Iran are being rounded up. ISPs were shut down, government hackers are threatening people who twitter, and some of them have vanished in the last 24 hours.

- Eventually, the people started to fight back. First, they took over and burned down a Basij base, killing its commander. Later, a Basij shot a young man in the face in front of their HQ, at which point a policeman went to confront them. The Basij beat the policeman, at which point students stormed the compound, throwing molotov cocktails, burning it to the ground.

- During the night, the police entered certain neighbourhood to arrest public servants and force them to appear at tomorrow's pro-Ahmadinejad manifestation, but the people went out in the street and forced them out of their neighbourhoods. The Basij have kept on storming dorms. So far the reports are conflicting, but it appears that the death toll could be as high as 40 for the protesters, with two dead on the side of the repressive militias. This is the end of the third wave.

early 16th of June - Supporters of Moussavi have a manifestation planned for 5pm, Tehran time. Roughly the same number or more is expected to attend. People are dressed in black and told to protest silently.

- The pro-Ahmadinejad crowd however are planning a counter-demonstration at the very same place the supporters are supposed to gather at 3pm. Most agree that basically they are simply going to gather for a confrontation. Rumours are that they are taking position in buildings next to the parade and in bunkers to attack. Basij from all over the country are moving to Tehran and supporters are being bused from all over the country. A major showdown is expected to unfold.

- The crackdown on people using telecommunication is as strong as ever. Anyone with a laptop, camera or cellphone is attacked in the street by plainclothes militias. Tehran hotels are under lockdown to prevent the members of the foreign press not yet expulsed from reporting what is happening.

- As for the Iranian Government and different branches, there are rumours that many Army Generals have been arrested for plotting a Coup d'État, but this is still speculation at this point. The Supreme Leader has also called for a 10-day inquiry into the claims of fraud, but it has been widely dismissed as cosmetic. Moussavi and his supporters have rejected this, claiming that they want new elections. Khameini is now using the armed Basij as his own bodyguards, hundreds of them are surround him and his residence to protect from attempted assassinations. Ahmadinejad himself is in Russia right now, for a planned visit, and tries to pretend that everything is good as usual.

early 16th of June - The fourth wave of violence has started, and was expected to flare up very soon. It surprisingly was quite mild. Pro-Moussavi supporters said that there were even more people today protesting against the regime, though raw numbers are hard to get. If this is true, it means there are more than 2M protesters in the street right now. They are dressed in black and protesting silently and without violence so far. Other reports that only 250,000 were in the street, possibly scared by the Basij and propaganda.

- The Basij, surprisingly, did not attacking the march itself but rather assaulted dorms again. It looks like they are using the march as a diversion. In Tehran proper, 2000 Basij are waiting to storm the male dorm, and they are backed by IRG helicopters, which seems to send the message that the IRG has broken from their undeclared neutrality toward tacitely supporting the Regime.

- The crackdown on telecommunications is starting to suffocate all of Iran. As of now:

* Gmail and GTalk are shut down
* Yahoo is shut down
* AIM is most likely shut down
* Phone lines are down
* HTTPS and other such protocols are down
* Iranian ISPs have been shut down
* They are trying very hard to close down the Iranian connexion to twitter and giving proxies they control in order to track down people
* Cellphones and SMS are shut down

People are also receiving phone calls from the government saying "We know you were in the protests".

Night has fallen on Iran, and the Basij are roaming, attacking passerbys at random. They have also surrounded dorms and waiting to storm them once again.

The Revolution lives on.

Demands from the protesters

1. Dismissal of Khamenei for not being a fair leader
2. Dismissal of Ahmadinejad for his illegal acts
3. Temporary appointment of Ayatollah Montazeri as the Supreme Leader
4. Recognition of Mousavi as the President
5. Forming the Cabinet by Mousavi to prepare for revising the Constitution
6. unconditional and immediate release of all political prisoners
7. Dissolution of all organs of repression, public or secret.

Who is Grand Ayatollah Montazeri?

Ayatollah Montazeri is a pro-Democracy, pro-Human Rights Ayatollah who was at one point on the short list of possible successors of Khomeini, but became marginalized as he adopted what was seen as a too pro-Western, pro-Democracy stance.

Since the beginning of the Revolution, he has been one of the fiercest critics of the Regime, and one of the biggest proponents of women and civil rights for ALL Iranians, including much-maligned minorities like the Baha'is. In fact he goes further than the protections afforded to them under Sharia.

He is also a big critic of Ahmadinejad and has been seen for years as the best hope for Iran if he ever was to come to power, something that was unthinkable a mere week ago.

He has also come out with a statement saying that policemen who beat on protesters and follow orders will not be forgiven under Islam, and that even if the government cuts the lines of communication with the outside world, that it was too late and the truth was getting out


important: The Iranian government is looking for dissident twitterers, so if you have an account, change your location and timezone to tehran!

Sunday, June 14, 2009

A Rational Discussion about the (former) Miss California

Take a look at the emails that were released by Miss CA USA to Fox News. Fox news presents the transcripts in a way that makes Ms. Prejean look pretty bad, but when the emails are read in the order they were sent, it is obvious that some of the emails were not included. It seems she didn't want the Miss CA USA people included while she was working with the Special Olympics. She didn't want to turn it into a public relations campaign. She wanted to volunteer and not have people like Keith Lewis dictating how she volunteered and when. Take a look at the Fox News Transcripts here, then read the emails in the order that they were sent below.

Here are the email transcripts from Fox News between Carrie Prejean (Miss CA until recently) and Keith Lewis (Executive Director of Miss CA USA):


From: "Keith Lewis"Date: Fri, 29 May 2009 07:19:18 -0700To: Carrie PrejeanSubject: FW: Messages

Carrie,

The Style Network has asked to schedule a general meeting. Generals in the entertainment field are an opportunity for casting and producing executives to gain a better understanding of a potential talents range and demeanor in order to consider them for future projects. They are done without a specific agenda. I have had great success with my actors who have taken generals and would suggest you give it strong consideration. You never know where it may lead and sometimes they develop entire shows around you. The following days are available to meet with them here in LA. Please let me know as soon as possible if any of them work for you.

Best regards,

Keith Lewis

---

From: cprejeanXXXXSent: Friday, May 29, 2009 7:38 AMTo: Keith LewisSubject: Re: Messages

What is this for?

Sent via BlackBerry by AT&T

---
Does it feel like a response from Keith Lewis should be here?
---

From: cprejeanXXXXSent: Friday, May 29, 2009 7:40 AMTo: Keith LewisSubject: Re: Messages

I expect you to be forwarding me ALL email requests and interview requests to me. I know how you are and its not right if you are selecting things for me. Thanks for your cooperation And fyi I am a presenter of medals at the special olympics in a few weeks for the summer games. So now u know I am doing this and I expect your full support. Also I was asked to fill in for a dj on a local radio show.. Ill be reading from a show biz script monday. I am doing this

Sent via BlackBerry by AT&T

---
And another response here?
---


From: cprejeanXXXXSent: Friday, May 29, 2009 7:42 AMTo: Keith LewisSubject: Re: Messages

Just as you need details for things so do I. Also nice move trying to make money off of my appearances Also.. Do not try and silence me by saying I do not have a comment about the prop 8 ruling. Maybe you don't. I do

Sent via BlackBerry by AT&T

---

From: "Keith Lewis"Date: Fri, 29 May 2009 07:43:45 -0700To: Subject: RE: Messages

Carrie,

It is for a general meeting - please see the explanation below.

Best regards,

Keith Lewis

---
I don't see any explanation. Did they cut out part of Keith's email? And I imagine they left out Carrie's response that would go here.
---

From: "Keith Lewis"Date: Fri, 29 May 2009 07:49:07 -0700To: Subject: RE: Messages

Carrie,

I have given you the details completely. Perhaps it is not something you would like to partake in, either way, you can let me know and I will respond to them today.

Best regards,

Keith Lewis

---

From: cprejeanXXXXSent: Friday, May 29, 2009 7:57 AMTo: Keith LewisSubject: Re: Messages

You do not cooperate with me, and you pick and chose the the things YOU want me to do. That is not happening anymore. Stop speaking for me. I have MY own voice. What are u gonna do fire me for volunteering for the special olympics hahaha ur crazy No I am doing this appearance. You do not need details. Its for the SPECIAL OLYMPICS!!! You just need to know I will be doing it alright

You will not facilitate this appearance

Sent via BlackBerry by AT&T

---
What made her send that last email? Seems like Keiths side of the conversation about the Special Olympics has been removed from the transcripts.
---

From: "Keith Lewis"Date: Fri, 29 May 2009 08:01:35 -0700To: Subject: RE: Messages

Carrie,

As we have discussed, there is proper protocol and we have not waived our rights in any way to your contract. I am happy to try and facilitate the request. Please forward over the information along with the proper contact and we will try and confirm the appearance right away.

Best regards,

Keith Lewis

---
He's telling her to send all of the information so Miss CA USA can "facilitate" the appearance.
---

From: cprejeanXXXXSent: Friday, May 29, 2009 10:09 AMTo: Keith LewisSubject: Re: Messages

Ok then I expect you to provide security per my request like you agreed to provide

Sent via BlackBerry by AT&T

---
She sends this email over two hours later. I assume it has to do with details about the Style Network General Meeting or another appearance. There is too big of a time gap to assume they are on the topic of the Special Olympics.
---

From: "Keith Lewis"Date: Fri, 29 May 2009 10:10:25 -0700To: Subject: RE: Messages

Carrie,

Although I do not agree with your directive nor is this letter an indication of our intent to waive our contract rights, we do not want to escalate the situation with you. In good faith, we will simply ask that you provide us all of the details so that we can block it in on our master calendar. We would also want to get the contact information should something come up - like you become missing after the event or you are in an accident before the event and need us to reach out for you. It is for your safety and our responsibility.

Best regards,

Keith Lewis

---
So he's telling her that they will let her do her volunteering for the Special Olympics on her own, but that they still have final say on her contract rights and that they want to know all of the details of the event.
---




It seems to me that Keith Lewis was telling her that Miss CA USA would be a part of her involvement as a volunteer in the Special Olympics("we have not waived our rights in any way to your contract") or she would not be doing them. I feel like there are many emails that were left out. The conversation in no way flows. What is Miss CA USA hiding? And why aren't any of the major news networks asking for ALL of the emails?

This whole thing leaves a bad taste in my mouth. Has Fox News really forgotten about journalistic integrity? Does Miss CA USA really expect noone to notice that they are just spinning their version of events?


Monday, June 1, 2009

A Rational Discussion on the Legalization of Marijuana

Reefer. Pot. Ganja. Mary Jane. Hippie Lettuce. Whatever you call it, marijuana has been a hot topic across the country recently.  California Assemblyman Tom Ammiano introduced Assembly Bill AB 390 for consideration in February, re-fanning the fire surrounding the legalization debate. While 13 states have legalized medicinal use, and a few municipalities have halted local enforcement of marijuana laws, the drug remains completely illegal in most states and, most importantly, at the federal level.  Pro-pot supporters applaud the new presidents stance on the issue, and were pleased to hear that he has told the DEA to honor the marijuana laws of each state.  Many legalization advocates are still pushing for more, however.  

We have all heard the argument that legalizing marijuana could help solve California's crippling budget crisis. The state is considering closing down %85 of its state parks due to budget shortfalls and a real possibility of the state running out of money in the next few months. Will the legalization and taxation really be enough to make even the smallest dent in our states death-roll to the bottom? The jury is still out on that one. 

Advocates say that we will not only benefit from the tax revenue from legal marijuana sales, but that we will save hundreds of millions of dollars on incarceration and enforcement costs. Quality will rise, the chance of ingesting even more harmful substances used to grow and harvest the plant will decrease, and it will take the drug profits out of the hands of criminals and put it into the coffers of the state.

Those who oppose legalization are sticking to the argument made since the first laws were passed limiting its use. The Marihuana Tax Act, passed in 1937, is the first federal restriction on the drug. Public hysteria reached fever pitch as news articles and anti-marijuana propaganda movies convinced the voting public that marijuana was a demonic weed, that it caused uncontrollable rages, and that one puff would send a person down the path of jazz and lunacy. Government officials were beginning to worry about the influx of Mexican immigrants across the southern border, many of which smoked marijuana after working long days of back breaking labor. 

Today's research shows that marijuana decreases response time while driving and retards the creation of short term memories. The drug can cause a psychological dependence, and has been shown to have a low degree of physical dependence in heavy, chronic users. For those with preexisting disorders such as arteriosclerosis, heart disease, and high blood pressure, marijuana can aggravate the symptoms by raising blood pressure and heart rate. On a statistical basis one marijuana joint can be equal to five cigarettes in terms of carbon monoxide intake, four cigarettes in terms of tar intake, and ten cigarettes in terms of the amount of microscopic damage done to the cells lining a persons airways.  There has been no proof, however, that marijuana smokers have an increased chance of developing cancer than those in the non-smoking population. 

While both sides are hashing out the pros and cons in the state legislature, marijuana continues to be California's largest cash crop.  The counties of Humboldt, Trinity, and Mendocino make up what is known as the "Emerald Triangle."  Some areas of these Northern California communities are dependant on the income made from growers, harvesters, and sellers living and working in their towns. With the lumber mills shutting down operation and all other industries slowing considerably, the residual profit from the illicit trade of marijuana is, at times, the only thing bringing residual income to local commercial and government pocketbooks.

Whether you are for or against the legalization of marijuana it is hard to believe that our governments, at the local, state, and federal levels will be able to sustain the prohibition of this plant for much longer. The "War on Drugs" has been an utter failure, the "Just Say No" mindset isn't a feasible option today, and DARE has been sucking money and resources from local law enforcement for years with little to no effect. Change will come not in the form of laws and regulations, but in the same way marijuana prohibition began in the first place: cultural and social acceptance/disapproval of the drug and all of the benefits and detriments it brings with it. 

To some, the thought of complete legalization may have only be a far off possibility even five years ago. It seems to us here at RD that the paradigm has shifted and that those seeking to keep the drug illegal may be the ones having the pipe dream.

Thursday, May 28, 2009

Coming soon...

A Rational Discussion on the legalization of marijuana in California..


Ideas for new RD articles are always welcome.

A Rational Discussion on CA's Prop 8 Fiasco

We start our story from the most logical place to start: the beginning. On June 2, 2008, Proposition 8 (Known officially as "Eliminates Rights of Same-Sex Couples to Marry. Initiative Constitutional Amendment.") was qualified for the November ballot by submitting 1,120,801 signatures. The organization Protect Marriage sponsored the initiative. Other supporters include Senator John McCain, The Roman Catholic Church, the Asian Heritage Coalition, the LDS church, and a number of other politicians and religious organizations. The proponents argued that exclusively heterosexual marriage was "an essential institution of society," that leaving the constitution unchanged would "result in public schools teaching our kids that gay marriage is okay," and that gays would "redefine marriage for everyone else." On November 5, 2008, Prop. 8 added Section 7.5 to Article I of the CA Constitution. Section 7.5 states: "Only marriage between a man and a woman is valid or recognized in California." 

This rendered obsolete the May 2008 ruling by the CA Supreme Court making laws preventing homosexual couples from getting married unconstitutional. The CASC ruled in May 2009 that the new Constitutional Amendment was valid and legal, making gay marriage unrecognized in California. Same sex marriages performed prior to November 5, 2008 are still recognized as valid.

Much has been made in the mass media (and the not-so-mass media) about the religious influence on the election. Many point fingers at the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints for turning the tide of public opinion in favor of Prop 8. Calls were made from the Church's leaders in Salt Lake that LDS members were to "do all you can to support the proposed constitutional amendment by donating of your means and time." Protect Marriage estimates that over half of its funds raised in support of Prop 8 came from "LDS Sources" with %45 of its out-of-state donations coming from Utah. Call center across the country used LDS church resources and member manpower to bombard California voters with pro- Prop 8 phone calls and messages.

Many people have a problem with the Mormon Church's involvement in the nations politics. Who ever said that an organized religious group does not have the right to make its voice heard? Every day a swarm of special interest lobbyists flock to the offices of those in power across the country.  What the LDS and other pro-Prop 8ers were doing strikes me as one of the most successful grassroots lobbying jobs in history. However, instead of lobbying our politicians, they were lobbying the voters.  

The Prop 8 battle shows that with enough money, scare tactics, and, a couple of flat out lies, coupled with pronouncements from religious leaders who are able to have a direct impact on their parishioners voting habits makes for a heavy weight that can be used to sway public opinion.

What Prop 8 has shown every Californian is that our laws can be altered and rights can be taken away with a simple majority vote. Now, if the US Constitution is amended to specifically allow gays the right to marry, section 7.5, Article I of the CA Constitution will be voided. This leads to another problem I will address in a later discussion: the issue of states rights.  

It is simply too easy for the majority to impose its will on the minority. This is why we had the Civil Rights movement. While the majority rules in terms of elections, we have set up protections for those in the minority. We are a nation that has always prided ourselves on ensuring individual freedoms. But before those freedoms were granted, a majority vote had stripped those rights away from the minority.  

The 15th Amendment to the US Constitution (February 3, 1870) did not include women as a group to be given the right to vote. It took 50 more years before the 19th Amendment was added, stating: "The right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any state on account of sex."

The "separate-but-equal" segregation laws legally written and enforced between 1876 and 1964 and were a legal avenue to continue discrimination of non-whites (for example: California's "Jim Crow" laws were aimed primarily toward the Chinese instead of African Americans. Idaho's were aimed at Native Americans) in the US. The laws passed concerning the protection of Civil Rights in the mid 1960's abolished nearly all legal segregation and non-inclusion.

This curtailing of a minority groups civil rights will be concluded as all other civil rights battles have concluded in this nation. We have created law that is unfair, bigoted, and infringes on the right to equal treatment that all Americans possess. Article 1, section 7.5 will be amended or repealed at some point, but we can all be sure that future generations will see the scar left and will mark this point in history as just another low in our nation's quest for liberty and justice for all. Equality, fairness, and the American foundation of freedom will prevail, whether we want it to or not.

I personally believe that homosexuals have the same right to marry the person of their choosing as I do. I feel that the governments part of the equation should only be the legal aspect of the contract itself, a civil-union record, if you will. If the majority of Californians feel that marriage is a practice steeped in religion, then we should allow each religion to decide what criteria are to be met before it performs its religious wedding ceremony. The wedding may not be a religious ceremony at all. But it is still a ceremony. It is time for the government to have less to do with ceremony, and more to do with ensuring equality in its legal and contractual obligations. It is time for Americans to stand up for freedom and equality for everyone, for their freedom could just as easily be extinguished the next time around.